Jackaby by William Ritter

I feel the need to state off the bat that I came into this book highly biased.  Jackaby has been touted by booksellers as "A cross between Sherlock and Doctor Who."  Now, anyone who's met me knows that I'm a freak for these shows.  My office is filled with Doctor Who things.  I have a sonic screwdriver.  (A student once asked me, "What is that?  A lightsaber?")  I have this cover from Entertainment Weekly up on my office wall.  I wore this t-shirt to school on Halloween. 
So, a book that's called a mash up of these two shows?  Um, yeah.  I'm all over it.

Jackaby is a paranormal mystery set in New England, 1892.  Abigail Rook arrives in town with no money, no job, and no husband, but with a healthy sense of adventure.  She answers an ad for "Investigated Services: Assistant Wanted."  The man who placed the ad is R.F. Jackaby, a private investigator who happens to be able to see spirits and inhuman creatures, and also wears a long, expensive coat and scarf.  Soon The Doctor and Clara Sherlock and Watson Jackaby and Abigail are investigating a string of grisly murders. 

For all the hype surrounding this book, I ultimately found Jackaby to be... fine.  I brought it home over Christmas break, and it sat on my coffee table for close to 2 weeks before I forced myself to finish it.  The "who done it" part of the mystery was not so hard to guess, although the paranormal aspect of it came out of slightly-left field.  Jackaby himself is certainly very Sherlock-ish.  He's an odd duck with a keen sense of observation that endears him few friends.  Abigail is given little to do other than to follow Jackaby around, although she has some skill at paying attention to details that eventually earns Jackaby's trust.

This book would be fine for middle school or high school, and at only 300 pages, is relatively short compared to many books coming out these days.  There's a good bit of odd humor (Jackaby's former assistant has been magically turned into a duck, for instance, thanks to a spell gone wrong), but I just wish it was more suspenseful.